Contested Divorce Attorney in Buffalo & Williamsville, NY
Reviewed for legal accuracy by Pieter G. Weinrieb, Esq. · Admitted NY 2005
When you and your spouse cannot agree on the terms of your divorce, you need attorneys who are fully prepared to take your case to trial, and skilled enough to settle it strategically short of one.
What Makes a Divorce “Contested”?
Child Support Calculator
Estimate support under New York’s CSSA formula.
Custody & Parenting Time Planner
Estimate schedules and overnight percentages.
A divorce is contested when the spouses cannot reach agreement on one or more core issues: child custody and parenting time, child support, spousal maintenance (alimony), division of marital property and assets, allocation of marital debt, or exclusive use and occupancy of the marital home. The spouses do not have to disagree on everything, even a single unresolved issue can make a divorce contested.
Under New York’s no-fault ground, either spouse can file on the ground that the relationship has broken down irretrievably for at least six months, as long as one spouse says so under oath (DRL §170(7)). This means fault (adultery, abandonment, cruel treatment) is rarely the reason a case goes to trial. Instead, contested divorces turn on financial and parenting disputes that require judicial resolution. The same subdivision is why a no-fault divorce can still be contested: no judgment can be granted until property, maintenance, child support, counsel and expert fees, and custody and parenting time have all been settled by the spouses or decided by the court.
At Weinrieb Law, we prepare every contested case as if it will go to trial. That preparation is what allows us to negotiate from strength and, in most cases, achieve a settlement our clients would not have obtained otherwise.
Issues Most Commonly Contested
- Child custody and parenting time, who has legal decision-making authority, where the children live, and the day-to-day and holiday schedule
- Child support: the CSSA formula calculation, add-on expenses, and the income of a self-employed or underemployed spouse
- Spousal maintenance: whether maintenance is owed, the amount, and its duration based on the length of the marriage and the parties’ incomes
- Division of the marital home: whether to sell immediately, allow one spouse to buy out the other, or defer sale until children finish school
- Business interests: valuing and dividing ownership interests and goodwill. (Under DRL §236(B)(5)(d)(7), the enhanced earning capacity from a professional license or degree is not itself distributable property, though the other spouse’s contributions to it remain a factor the court must consider.) For how experts arrive at a number, see how a business is valued in a New York divorce.
- Retirement accounts and pensions: dividing 401(k)s, defined benefit plans and government pensions through QDROs or DROs. (IRAs are divided by a transfer incident to divorce under IRC §408(d)(6), not a QDRO.)
- Allocation of marital debt: credit cards, mortgages, business loans, and tax liabilities incurred during the marriage
- Dissipation of assets, addressing money spent on an affair, gambling, or hidden assets
The Contested Divorce Process in New York
The following is a general roadmap for a contested divorce in Erie County. Every case moves at its own pace depending on the court’s calendar, the complexity of the issues, and the parties’ willingness to cooperate.
- Filing the Summons and Complaint: The plaintiff files with the Erie County Supreme Court and serves the defendant. The defendant must appear within 20 days if served in person, or within 30 days if served another way, such as substituted service (CPLR 320(a)). When a complaint is served, the appearance is usually a Verified Answer, which may include counterclaims.
- Temporary Relief: Either party may immediately move for temporary orders covering child custody, support, exclusive use of the home, and restraints on dissipating marital assets. Temporary orders govern the parties’ lives until a final judgment is entered.
- Preliminary Conference: Once the case is assigned to a judge, the court orders a preliminary conference within 45 days (22 NYCRR §202.16[f]) to identify contested issues, set a discovery schedule, and issue a conference order. Both spouses must attend in person, and sworn statements of net worth, three years of tax returns and account statements, and current pay stubs are exchanged at least 10 days beforehand. You can start yours now with our Statement of Net Worth form.
- Discovery: The parties exchange financial documentation: tax returns, pay stubs, bank and investment account statements, business records, retirement account statements, credit card statements, and appraisals. This phase often reveals hidden assets or income discrepancies. Our guide to the discovery process in a New York divorce walks through each tool in detail.
- Compliance Conference: The court reviews discovery progress and resolves any outstanding disclosure disputes.
- Expert Retention: Complex cases may require forensic accountants to value a business, actuaries to value pension benefits, real estate appraisers, or vocational experts to assess a spouse’s earning capacity.
- Certification and Pre-Trial Conference: Once discovery is complete, the parties certify readiness for trial. The court holds a pre-trial conference to narrow the issues and encourage settlement.
- Trial: A non-jury trial before a Supreme Court Justice. Both sides present testimony, documents, and expert witnesses. The judge issues a Decision After Trial, followed by a Judgment of Divorce.
Most cases in Erie County resolve before trial, often at or after the pre-trial conference when both sides see the full evidence picture. But the cases that do go to trial require attorneys with genuine courtroom experience. Our case results show representative outcomes in contested matters.
Two rules that shape a contested case early
Issues you do not name at the preliminary conference can be lost. At the close of the conference, the court has the parties put on the record every issue of fault, custody and finance that remains unresolved. An issue not described then may not be raised later in the case unless good cause is shown (22 NYCRR §202.16[f][3]). The rule also sets the pace: discovery is to be finished and the note of issue filed within six months of the conference unless the court changes that schedule. We prepare for the preliminary conference the way we prepare for a hearing, and we want your financial documents in hand before it.
The spouse with less money does not have to fight unfunded. New York law creates a rebuttable presumption that counsel fees will be awarded to the less monied spouse, and the court may also direct payment of expert fees such as accountants, appraisers and actuaries (DRL §237(a), (d)). Fees can be awarded while the case is pending, so that both sides are adequately represented from the start. Our guide to who pays attorney fees in a New York divorce explains how these applications work, and our page on temporary orders covers the other early relief available.
Filing a contested case also does not close the door on out-of-court resolution. Parties in active litigation can, and often do, take discrete issues to private mediation while the court case continues, or use the leverage of a firm trial date to negotiate a global settlement. Litigating and settling are not opposites; handled well, each strengthens the other. For clients in the city itself, our Buffalo divorce attorneys page covers what to expect in cases venued at the Erie County courthouse downtown.
Frequently Asked Questions
How long does a contested divorce take in New York?
In Erie County, most contested divorces take between 12 and 24 months from filing to final judgment, though highly complex cases or those involving custody disputes can run longer. Cases with minimal discovery disputes and cooperative parties can sometimes conclude in 9 to 12 months. Pieter will give you a candid assessment of likely timing based on your specific facts during your consultation.
Can a contested divorce become uncontested?
Yes: and this happens frequently. Many couples who start out bitterly opposed reach a negotiated settlement once discovery is complete and each side sees the realistic range of outcomes. Settling before trial eliminates the unpredictability of a judge’s ruling and significantly reduces legal fees and emotional toll. At Weinrieb Law, we actively pursue settlement at every stage while maintaining full trial readiness.
What are temporary orders and why do they matter?
We obtain temporary orders early in the case to govern who has custody of the children, who stays in the marital home, how much temporary child support and maintenance are paid, and what financial restraints apply to both parties. They matter enormously because they often establish the “status quo” that a court is reluctant to disrupt. Getting the right temporary orders early in the case can be as important as the final judgment.
Do I have to go to court personally?
For most conferences, your attorney can attend without you. However, you will be required to appear for a preliminary conference, a deposition or examination before trial, and any trial proceedings. We prepare clients thoroughly for every court appearance.
How is fault treated in a contested divorce?
New York is a no-fault state, so proving fault is not required to obtain a divorce, and fault rarely changes how property is divided. New York’s highest court has held that marital fault counts in equitable distribution only in egregious cases that shock the conscience of the court, and that adultery on its own does not qualify (Howard S. v Lillian S., 14 NY3d 431 [2010]). Some conduct is treated differently because the statute names it: domestic violence and the wasteful dissipation of assets are listed property-division factors (DRL §236[B][5][d][12], [14]), and acts that have inhibited a spouse’s earning capacity, including domestic violence, are a listed maintenance factor (DRL §236[B][6][e][1][g]). In custody, the only question is the child’s best interests, so a parent’s conduct matters to the extent it bears on the children.
Can we agree on some issues but still have the court decide others?
Absolutely. Partial settlements are common and encouraged. If the parties can resolve property and financial issues but cannot agree on custody, only the custody question goes to trial. Narrowing the contested issues reduces cost and shortens the timeline significantly.
Get a Consultation
Tell us about your situation. We respond within one business day: confidential and no obligation.
For urgent matters, call (716) 759-4529.
Further Reading
Complete Guide to Divorce in New York
12 pages covering equitable distribution, maintenance, child custody, timelines and more: written by Weinrieb Law attorneys.